[Music]
[音乐]
are you familiar with the extinct
你知道爱丁堡亚瑟
volcano that is Arthur's seat in
王座这座死火山吗
Edinburgh yes were you on Arthur's seat
？是的，你九月二号在亚瑟王座上吗
on the second of September
yes did you hear any anything out of the
？是的，你听到过什么异常的声音吗？
ordinary I heard a
我听到一声
scream want to emergency we're up on
尖叫，想紧急救援，我们 在
Arthur's seat near to the very top of it
亚瑟座位的顶部附近，
uh we heard someone screaming there's a
我们听到有人尖叫，这里有个
guy here he said his wife would fall off
男人，他说他的妻子会
of The Edge I think right what part of
从边缘掉下来，我想是的，
our officers know the more vertical
我们的警官们知道越垂直的
side the mean charge is that the accused
一侧，平均指控是被告
did assault his wife FIA javeed and did
确实殴打了他的妻子 FIA javeed 并且确实
push her from height at Arthur's seat in
在爱丁堡的亚瑟王座上将她从高处推下，
Edinburgh and was so severely injured
伤势严重导致
that she died and he did murder her a
她死亡，他确实谋杀了她 一名
man has been arrested in connection with
男子因涉嫌
the suspicious death of a woman who fell
一名从亚瑟王座上坠落的女子的可疑死亡而被捕
from Arthur's seat you have no evidence
没有证据
to tell you what happened on the hill
告诉你山上发生了什么
you're just being asked to take a
你只是被要求进行
massive
大胆的
guess the accused will maintain that
猜测被告将坚持认为
this was simply an
这只是一场
accident how then does the crow
意外那么乌鸦如何
demonstrate that there was a deliberate
证明有故意的
push I've prosecuted many murder cases
推搡我已经 被起诉
over the course of my career but for a
在我的职业生涯中，我处理过很多谋杀案，但由于
variety of reasons reasons this case is
各种原因，这个案子
extraordinary for Foria mom and indeed
对 Foria 的妈妈和整个家庭来说都是非同寻常的，
the whole family this is a very
这是一个非常
emotional and difficult
情绪化和困难的
time they have attended all the way from
时刻，他们从
leads to be
线索到
here it's going to be a traumatic time
现在一直参与其中，这将是 对我们所有人来说都是一段痛苦的时光，
for all of us I know I'm going to come
我知道我将要
face to face with him this person has
面对他，这个人
destroyed us
毁了我们
we all want to know what actually
我们都想知道
happened to FIA and we'll fight to get
FIA 到底发生了什么，我们将为获得
ad Justice and
正义和
answers
答案而战
wa if there's one memory I have about
wa 如果说我对 FIA 有什么记忆的话，那
FIA is just laughing you come from FIA
就是笑，你来自 FIA，她
was almost like a a Wonder Woman she was
几乎就像一个神奇女侠，她很
smart she was beautiful some would say
聪明，很漂亮，有些人会说
she had it
她拥有它
all as the trial starts what's going
当审判开始时，
through your
你在
mind
想什么，
hat ha for
哈哈
him right good morning everyone mag
他，早上好，大家好，
deput uh what's happening first today
副总统，呃，今天首先发生了什么，
thank you my Lord the first witness for
谢谢大人，王室的第一位证人
the crown is number 26 on the crown list
是王室名单上的第 26 位，
all right thank you the key issue is
好的，谢谢，关键问题是
what happened on Arthur's seat so I will
亚瑟王座上发生了什么，所以我将以
open the case with one of the witnesses
一个问题开始这个案件
who was on the hill at the time however
当时在山上的目击者，但
we don't have an eyewitness other than
我们不知道 除了被告之外还有目击证人，
the accused the defense might argue that
辩方可能会争辩说
there's insufficient evidence to justify
没有足够的证据证明
murder so it's up to me to prove the
谋杀是正当的，所以由我来证明案件
case Beyond A Reasonable
Doubt have you been on Arthur seat on
无可置疑，你多次坐过亚瑟座位吗？
many occasions yes would I be right in
是的，我
saying there are several roots that one
说的对吗？有几个
can take to get to the summit mhm
到达山顶需要走的路，嗯
correct is it an area which is prone to
对吗，这是一个适合
Recreation with lots of people walking
休闲娱乐的地方，据我所知，有很多人在那里散步
up there to my knowledge
yes there's a good view of Edinburgh
from the top is that correct
是的，从山顶可以欣赏到爱丁堡的美景，对吗
yes were you on Arthur's seat on the 2nd
是的，2021 年 9 月 2 日你在亚瑟王座上吗？
of September 2021
yes did you hear anything out of the
是的，你听到什么异常声音了吗？
scream could you tell if it was a male
尖叫，你能分辨出是男性
or female
还是女性的
scream there were a couple of Screams
尖叫声吗？有几声尖叫声，
one was from a female screaming and then
一个是女性的尖叫声，然后
I heard a male
我听到一个男人
screaming and then I saw a gentleman
在尖叫，然后我看到一位先生
coming down uh basically asking for help
走下来，呃，基本上是在寻求帮助，
very
非常
panicked would you recognize the male if
惊慌失措，如果
you saw him again yes could you look
你再次见到他，你会认出那个男人吗？是的，你能
around the court and tell me if you see
环顾一下球场，告诉我你是否
him there and just for the record
在那里看到他，然后 为了
purposes you've pointed to the the man
你指出的记录目的，
between the two security officers in the
被告席上两名安全官员之间的那名男子
dock is that
是否
correct was any explanation offered to
正确，有没有得到任何
you as to what had happened uh the
关于发生的事情的解释，呃，那位
gentleman said that his wife had fallen
先生说，他的妻子
off of Arthur seat off of the summit and
从山顶的亚瑟座椅上摔了下来
he wanted me to dial 999 and did you do
他要我拨打 999，你打了吗？
that yes I'm going to play a recording
是的，我要播放一段录音，
which is label number one trible 9
上面写着标签 1 号 trible 9
call emergency hey we're up on Arthur's
紧急呼叫嘿，我们在亚瑟的
seat near the very top of it we heard
座位上，靠近最顶端，我们听到
someone screaming and there's a guy here
有人尖叫，还有 这里有一个人，
he said his wife had fallen off of The
他说他的妻子从边缘掉了下来，
Edge I think right what part of oured
我想是的，我们那边的哪个部分，
they also there's no the more vertical
他们也没有更垂直的
side are you able to approach the mail
一侧，你能去邮件吗，
hey bud I'm on the phone with the
伙计，我正在和
Emergency
紧急
Services she's on the other side yeah oh
服务部门通电话，她在 另一边是的哦
you okay
你还好吗
buddy do we need an ambulance uh do you
伙计我们需要救护车吗呃你
need an ambulance you think yeah 100%
需要救护车你觉得是的100%
that's what I thought listen I'll get
我就是这么想的听着我会
someone there as soon as we can okay
尽快派人去好的
yeah no problem thank
没问题谢谢
you
你
after that point what happened the
之后发生了什么 这位
gentleman kept trying to go over to to
先生一直想过
get the woman who had fallen but uh he
去拿 那个女人摔倒了，但他
was struggling to get up there I think
挣扎着站起来，我想
it was just his shoes or it was just
那只是他的鞋子，或者
slippy at the time and did you receive a
当时只是滑了，你有没有接到
call back from the emergeny services the
急救部门的回电，
ambulance service in particular yes did
特别是救护车服务部门的回电，是的，
the man you've identified also speak on
那个男人 我已经确定了，也在电话里说
the telephone
yes I you with position at the moment no
是的，我和你现在的立场
no
no the you're not with it at the moment
不不不你现在不同意，
that anything completely
完全
BL exactly what's happen toward the edge
BL到底发生了什么，朝着边缘走去
and there was a bit of a he was walking
，有一点他走进
in front of us and SL rocks whatever you
来 在我们面前和 SL 岩石无论你怎么
call
称呼
the you
no I I
不我我
fli we both technically and then I arm
飞我们两个技术上然后我手臂
she she
她她
went and
去了和
what was walking on thaty Rock i i i my
那块岩石上行走我我我
further I
进一步我
get and is
得到和有
any is she
任何她
bleeding
流血
hello is she breeding
你好她在繁殖吗
[ 音乐]
Al the Poli R now I'll leave you with
Al the Poli R 现在我会把你留给
the police all
警察
right all right thank you very much Mr D
好的好的非常感谢 D 先生
good how many times have you been up to
好你有多少次登上
the summit on Arthur's seed I would say
亚瑟种子峰的顶峰我会说
over hundred most of my life have been
超过一百次我一生中的大部分时间都
going up there so all right so you are
爬上去，所以你
aware of part of the summit which
知道山顶的一部分
descends quite rapidly from um I suppose
从那里下降得相当快 嗯，我想
the top of some Crags or rocks or Cliffs
一些峭壁或岩石或悬崖的顶部
is that right yes I do my best to avoid
是的，是的，我尽力避免
it and I take it you do your best to
它，我认为你尽力
avoid it because you know about it yes
避免它，因为你知道它是的，是的，是的
is that right yes so when you're on the
，所以当你在
summit you know how to descend from the
山顶你知道如何从山顶下来
summit and where not to go is that
，哪里不能去，对吗？
correct
correct now you were explaining how the
现在你在解释
man whom you've identified appeared to
你识别出的那个人似乎
be slipping is that right yes he
在滑倒，对吗？是的，他
appeared to be losing balance and I
似乎失去了平衡，我
think you used the description of him as
想你用过 对他
being very panicked correct I take it
非常恐慌的描述是正确的，我认为
that was the impression you gained of
这就是你对
his situation is that correct yes
他的情况的印象，是正确
correct thank you very
的，非常感谢
[音乐]，
much the start point for any defense in
a case is the instructions you have from
案件中任何辩护的起点都是你从被告那里得到的指示
the accused so the accused says I didn't
所以被告说我没有
commit this crime here's the
犯这个罪，这是
circumstances can you defend
情况，你能为我辩护吗，
me accused persons deserve the best
被告应该得到
representation that the law can provide
法律所能提供的最好的辩护，
and you give every case everything
你对每一个案件都
you've got really that's the way I see
尽了最大的努力，我真的是这么认为的，
it
this is my favorite one
这是我最喜欢的 一个
F maybe she just had a bath and she's
F 也许她刚洗完澡，她
just
就
so giggly and
咯咯地笑，很
happy so
开心，所以
natural the life I had that's gone it's
自然的生活，我过得就是这样 走了，一切都
finished closy was our life she's our
结束了，我们的生活就是她我们的
world our
世界我们的
everything sorry I can't do
一切，对不起，我不能再做
anymore
了，
fosy was an angel on
fosy是地球上的天使，
Earth me and my husband could have asked
我和我的丈夫本可以
for B
要求B
baby she attracted attention wherever
宝贝，无论她走到哪里，她都会引起人们的注意，
she went you know anybody that come to
你知道任何人 来到
the door should go running and just
门口的人应该跑过去和
start chatting to them so extrovert so
他们聊天，她性格
outgoing everybody just fell in love
外向，每个人都爱上了
with
her
她，
and at the age of eight she wanted to
八岁时她想
become a
成为一名
lawyer she stood for fairness and
律师，她代表公平和
Justice even at that age you could just
正义，即使在那个年龄你也可以
tell she' always said to me m m in
告诉她总是对我说旁遮普语中的 m m
Punjabi it means Uncle she's always in M
意思是叔叔她总是在 M
how are
you Yasmin invested all her hard work in
你好吗 Yasmin 将她所有的辛勤工作都投入到了
FIA and FIA was only one in the family
FIA 中，而 FIA 是家里唯一一个
to be educated privately he has me was
接受私人教育的人，他有我
probably around5 an hour and she used to
大概 5 岁 她以前每小时要
pay like 20 an hour for private
付20块钱上私人
tuition okay remember the graduation day
课程，记得毕业那天
she was saying to me that I'm going to
她对我说我要
become a lawyer and to make you very
成为一名律师，让你感到非常
proud now was like the happiest time of
自豪，那是我一生中最快乐的时光
my life seeing her you know doing
知道如何
well on a boat right now it's not
在船上表现良好 现在还没有
setting off but I think we're all all
出发，但我想我们都
feeling scared
感到害怕，
my we did a lot of things together
我们一起做了很多事情，一起
lunches together holidays
吃午饭，一起度假
together she took us to places that I
她带我们去了我
would never have ever dreamt of
做梦也想不到的地方
going oh that's so cute if only Tuesday
去哦，那是 真可爱如果只有星期二
your
你的
Wednesday oh my God the water is so
星期三哦天哪水是如此
go it wasn't a question of mother and
之流这不是母女的问题
daughter they were best friends they
她们是最好的朋友她们
were very
close just breaks my heart when I see
亲密当我看到它不再发生时我的心都碎了
that it's no
longer going to happen
anymore yes have a good day who's next
是的，祝你有美好的一天，下一个是谁，
please my Lord the next witness is
请大人下一位证人是
number five on the crown list neat
皇冠名单上的第五位，整洁的
Yasmin
Yasmin
jav it's going be very painful for my
jav，对我的
sister to give evidence but she's very
妹妹来说，提供证据会非常痛苦，但她非常
brave and we know she's going to do this
勇敢，我们知道她会这样做
Foria would you say these words back to
Foria 你会 请把这些话告诉
me please yes sure I solemnly sincerely
我 是的，我庄严、
and truly I
真诚、真实地
solemnly truly and sincerely declare and
声明并确认 我庄严、真诚、真诚地
affirm declare and affirm that I will
声明并确认 我将
tell the truth that I will tell the
说实话 我将说
truth the whole truth the whole truth
实话 全部事实 全部事实
and nothing but the truth and nothing
只有事实 只有事实
but the truth thank you very much yes
但事实上非常感谢 是的，祝
have a good deut thank
you now are you nihat Yasmin Javed more
你有个好结局，谢谢你，你现在叫 Yasmin Javed，更
commonly known as Yasmin that's ja yes
广为人知的名字是 Yasmin，是的，
and did you have a daughter
你有一个女儿
Foria yes that's right
Foria 是的，
yeah where are you close to your
没错，你在哪里，和你
daughter very close she was an only
女儿很亲近，她是
child what was her occupation she was a
独生女，她的职业是什么 她是一名
solicitor employment law employment
律师 劳动法 劳动
law did she form a relationship with a
法 她是否与一个
man called Kashif anir that's right yes
叫 Kashif anir 的男人建立了关系 是啊 是
and do you recognize him yeah just point
的 你认识他吗 是的
to him please sir you've pointed to the
请指着他 先生 你指着那个
man in the do between the two security
男人 在两个保安
officers tell us us how that
人员之间告诉 我们，我们，我们之间的
relationship came about when the accused
关系是怎么产生的，当时被告
was working as a optical assistant in
是一名光学助理，
leads I went in there to
我和 Folia 一起去那里
purchase some glasses accompanied by
买眼镜，
Folia so it was like friendly chitchat
所以就像友好的闲聊一样，
and then um fosy worked in the city
然后 fosy 在市中心工作，
center and they bumped into each other
他们碰到了彼此
one day and he actually said to her look
有一天他居然对她说，看，
um this is the type of girl I want to
这就是我想娶的那种女孩。
marry
don't do that way cash when I met him he
不要那样做，当我遇到他时，他
was very very
confident
自信，
he came across as a very caring young
他给人的印象是一个非常有爱心的
person very
年轻人，非常
genuine I'm bra my she's fre dor an she
真诚 我是胸罩，她是fre dor 她
do falling
确实爱上了
Al F was a practicing Muslim and Faith
Al F 是一名虔诚的穆斯林，信仰
was important to him as
对他来说很重要
well
嗯
they seemed really happy
他们在一起看起来很幸福
together he told her that she had
他告诉她，她拥有
everything that he was looking for in a
他想要的
wife beautiful independent
妻子的一切 美丽独立
[Applause]
[掌声]
intelligent
聪明，
he said he wanted to be a very good
他说他想成为一个很好的
husband to
丈夫
FIA FIA was happy with him me and my
FIA FIA 和他在一起很开心，我和我
husband were happy with him you know
丈夫和他在一起很开心，你知道
there was no reason to think
没有理由认为不是
otherwise did Fus view of the
这样，Fus 对关系的看法有
relationship
change um the accused seemed a bit
改变吗 嗯，被告似乎有点
um
possessive um a bit of a hot
占有欲，嗯，脾气有点
temper did you ever see any example of a
暴躁，你见过暴躁的例子吗？
hot temper yeah we were on the way to
是的，我们当时正在
get the Rings we got into the car we all
去拿戒指的路上，我们上了车，我们都
had our seat belts on apart from the
系好了安全带，除了
accused and Folia told him to put his uh
被告和 Folia 告诉他系好
seat belt on and he refused F said to
安全带，但他拒绝了。F 对
him look I could get into trouble and
他说，看，我可能会惹上麻烦，
and he just snapped he got really really
然后他就发怒了，他非常非常
angry shouting and swearing and
生气，大喊大叫，咒骂，
screaming it was something that I'd
尖叫，这是我
never seen before it was an extreme
从未见过的事情 这是一个极端的
reaction but he was very very apologetic
反应，但他非常非常抱歉 向
he apologized to me he apologized to
我道歉他向
foosia he told me that he was stressed
foosia 道歉他告诉我他
out with his
studying and I believe
学习压力太大我相信
him there was something about him that
他身上有某种东西
was Bing me there was just something
是 Bing 的我身上有某种东西
about him that I didn't
是我不知道的
[音乐 ]
like
就像
when I first met him I was speaking to
我第一次见到他的时候，我正在跟
his father introducing myself and then
他父亲介绍我自己，然后
he just cut in it goes I forget my
他就打断了我，说我忘了我的
father and he spoke over me and I didn't
父亲，他打断了我说话，我不
喜欢
that his Cockiness and his iGun pop me
他的自大，他的 iGun
off straight
立刻把我打断了，
away she was like a a Bentley
她 就像是宾利
Continental one of my favorite cars yeah
欧陆，我最喜欢的车之一，是的，
and he was like a Nissan
他就像日产
mic but FIA was happy with him FIA made
麦克风，但国际汽联对他很满意，国际汽联做出了
her choice and I had to accept
选择，我不得不接受这个
that look at
事实，看着
me Andy even if you want to come around
我安迪，即使你想再多走一步，
a little bit more right around here yeah
对吧 在这里，是的，
yeah and then just place it across yeah
是的，然后就把它放在对面，是的，
Lely
莱利
smile he was was an
微笑，他是一个
absolutely stunning beautiful bride you
绝对令人惊艳的美丽新娘，你
sure look nice yes baby my sh
看起来真漂亮，是的，宝贝，
look when FIA married him at the mosque
当 FIA 在清真寺嫁给他时，我的 sh 看起来
FIA was very
FIA 非常
happy in our culture the girl always
在我们的文化中，女孩总是
goes to the boy side of the family
去男孩那​​边的家庭
so after the ceremony py would live with
所以仪式结束后，Py 会和
his parents and her
他的父母以及她的
husband he and his parents had actually
丈夫住在一起，他和他的父母实际上已经
come to our house and I made it
来到我们家，我
absolutely crystal clear that fos could
非常清楚地表明，fos 可以
do the basics but she wasn't going to be
做基本的事情，但她不会
doing housework and cooking all day
做家务，
because she was a Cay woman she was a
因为她是凯伊女人，她是一名
lawyer she wasn't a housewife put it
律师，她不是家庭主妇，所以她整天都在做饭，
that way and absolutely fine with that
这么说吧，而且完全没问题，
all three of them saw FIA went to live
她们三个都看到了 FIA，和她们一起生活了
them so I first met FIA in 2018 when I
所以我第一次见到 FIA 是在 2018 年，当时 我
first joined the firm and we just
刚加入公司的时候，我们
clicked sometimes during a lunch break
有时会在午休时间
with uh grab bubble tea that was our
一起喝珍珠奶茶，这是我们的
thing we used to grab bubble tea and go
爱好，我们过去常常一起喝珍珠奶茶，去
to a
park she was very charismatic he was
公园，她很有魅力，
absolutely impossible for you to not to
你绝对不可能不喜欢
love
her stay there second do that again are
她 第二个，
you because of the co restrictions not
你是不是因为合作限制，没有
many people from work could be invited
多少同事能被邀请
to the wedding so FIA texted me a few
参加婚礼，所以 FIA
days after the ceremony actually
在仪式实际发生几天后给我发短信，
happened hello my little ingredient just
你好，我的小成分，只是
wanted to drop you a quick message to
想给你发一条快速信息，
say I got Mar married last last week
说我 上周 Mar 结婚了，
um um and I told her congratulations and
我向她表示祝贺，
she replied thank you hopefully we can
她回复说谢谢，希望我们能
celebrate
soon she sent me some photographs from
尽快庆祝。她给我发了一些
from the
wedding I remember I told her that she
婚礼照片，我记得我告诉她，她
looked
看起来很
beautiful the next time we saw other was
漂亮。下次我们见面是
in a shopping center and we went for
在购物中心，我们一起去喝
bubble
珍珠
tea she never talked about kashi's
奶茶。她从来没有谈起过卡西的
parents one thing I did find strange was
父母 有一件事我觉得很奇怪，
um every time she would refer to them
每次她提到他们时，
she would she would say the people I
她都会说和我一起生活的人
live
with she was taking a lot of pictures
more than usual and it sort of gave me
比平时拍了很多照片，这让我觉得
the impression she was sending them to
她把这些照片发给了我 有
somebody
Kashi called at some point and he asked
一次 Kashi 打电话给某人，他问
FIA if we wanted to go for a pizza um
FIA 我们是否想去吃披萨，
and then she said no I don't think
然后她说不，我觉得
Ingrid's hungry um and that was
Ingrid 不饿，然后就是这样
it so far as you're aware was FIA
据你所知是 FIA
someone who would use social media yes
某人 谁会使用社交媒体？是的，
she did yes
她确实使用
did her use of social media change at
社交媒体了。在与阿诺尔先生交往期间，她对社交媒体的使用是否有所改变？是的，
all while in the relationship with Mr
anoir yeah in what way um she
以何种方式？嗯，她
deactivated her Facebook account why was
停用了她的 Facebook 帐户，为什么
that because the accused said to her
？因为被告对她说，
that I'm I'm not on Facebook and it'll
我是我' 我不玩 Facebook，所以
be good to just concentrate on the
最好把注意力集中在
marriage rather than being on social
婚姻上，而不是沉迷于社交
media and she took that on board yeah
媒体和 她接受了这个事实，是的，
were you aware of FIA having blocked any
你知道 FIA 屏蔽了她的
family members or friends from social
家人或朋友的社交
media FIA hadn't but the accused had got
媒体吗？FIA 没有，但被告
into her phone and started blocking mail
进入了她的手机，开始屏蔽
members of the family did she ever tell
家人的邮件，她有没有告诉
you anything about money having been
你关于钱的事
transferred from her account she did she
她
said that the accused one day while she
说，有一天，被告趁她
was asleep logged into her bank account
睡觉时登录了她的银行账户，
online and withdrew
取出了
£12,000 and put it into his
12,000 英镑，存入了他的
account
账户，
were you aware of telephone calls from
你是否知道
Mr anoir to your daughter yes I
阿诺尔先生给你女儿打过电话，是的，我
overheard pH
听到了 pH
conversations so this is her room yeah
对话所以这是她的房间是的，
yeah
是
yeah and have you changed much
的，是的，你有没有改变很多
没有
I remember it was Ramadan and she'd come
我记得那是斋月，她会
back home to stay with
回家和我们住在一起
us she was upstairs in her room and I
她在楼上的房间里，我
could hear his voice on that phone call
能听到 他的声音在电话里响起
and I was just besides
，我当时简直是
myself I'm going to play a recording
忘乎所以，我要播放一段录音，
which is Crown label 8 which are calls
是 Crown label 8 的录音，是
recorded on the 30th of April 2021
2021 年 4 月 30 日录制的电话
my Lord the first call is Crown
天哪，第一个电话是 Crown
production
production
103 in terms of moving forward what are
103 的，就 前进，
you going to do are you going to come
你打算做什么 你要做什么，你
back tomorrow like I've told you to I
明天会像我告诉你的那样回来吗，我
don't have the answer to that this is
不知道答案，这是
the last time I'm going to call you by
我最后一次给你打电话，顺便说一句，
the way if you don't come back tomorrow
如果你明天不回来，
I'm not to bother with these I'm going
我 我不会为这些烦恼，我会
to be very blunt about that Mom and Dad
直言不讳地说，妈妈和爸爸
want that anyway they want you out of my
想要这样，无论如何，他们希望你离开我的
life so they can get the little F back
人生，这样他们就可以把那个小F找回来，
little that's you Cas I'm not coming
那就是你，Cas，我
back tomorrow you're not coming back
明天不会回来了，你' 明天不会回来
tomorrow you're not coming back tomorrow
你明天不会回来
no who the who the [\h__\h] you think you
不谁你他妈的以为你是谁
are why you wearing at me
你为什么又对我发火
again you are incapable of CH who are
你没有能力 CH 你是谁
you listen to me I'm not going to call
听我说我不会
you again that's fine you said that I
再给你打电话了没关系 你说我
heard that loud and clear no no I'm not
听得很清楚不不我
going to no genu you might have blocked
不会不你可能也屏蔽了
me as well you bastard you now block me
我你这个混蛋你现在屏蔽了我
delete all the wedding delete everything
删除所有的婚礼删除所有的
that's fine that's fine that's fine
没关系没关系没关系
because that's what you that's what you
因为那就是你那就是 你
are disease in everyone's life the
是每个人生命中的疾病，
sooner you're dead or the sooner you're
你死得越早，或者你死得越早
out my life it'll be
离开我的生活会
better you're a disease in everyone's
更好你是每个人生命中的疾病
life the sooner you're dead or the
你越早死或者
sooner you're out of my life it'll be
你越早离开我的生活会
better what was fia's reaction to that
更好国际汽联对这种评论的反应是什么
sort of comment upset extremely
很难过非常
upset and the next part also on the same
难过 下一部分也在同
day this time it is Crown production 25
一天，这次是 Crown production 25，
please do I not have a say in how I want
请问我对
my life with you oh you can't with what
和你一起的生活没有发言权吗，哦，你不能和你在一起，
with what cuz you're married now yeah
因为你现在已经结婚了，是的，
but can I not have a say can I not have
但是我不能 有发言权我能没有
an opinion you being a [\h__\h] when I told
意见你是个婊子当我告诉
you your husband told you come back
你的时候你的丈夫叫你
tomorrow why the [\h__\h] are you not
明天回来你他妈的为什么不
listening look at how you speaking to me
听看你是怎么跟我说话的
how are you going to you You' been told
你要怎么对你你被告知
to come back tomorrow how are youh cash
要来 明天回来你好吗现金
I'm saying that you can't accept that
我说你不能接受
you have a problem and that you need to
你有问题而且你需要
change I will genuinely pull out next
改变我会真诚地退出
time said that I need help you got that
下次说我需要帮助你得到那笔
cash stoping that cash cash listen
现金停止那笔现金现金
listen listen I'm telling you your
听听听 我告诉你，你
husband you're coming back tomorrow get
老公，你明天就回来，
yourself back to you tomorrow like I've
明天就回到你身边，就像我
said stop challenging me cuz you're not
说的，别再挑战我了 你
going to get anywhere in life you just
不会在生活中取得任何成就，你只是在
challenged me especially with this
挑战我，特别是这个，
you're not you know who do you think you
你不是，你知道你以为你
are you're not a man start behaving like
是谁，你不是男人，开始像个女人一样行事，
a woman do not be that British woman I'm
不要成为那个英国女人，我
telling you now it's not going to work
告诉你 你现在不会工作了
you're coming back tomorrow cuz you were
你明天回来因为你被
told
告知
her how you're a horrible person if you
你是一个多么可怕的人如果你
look so you don't treat them the way
看起来所以你不要像你那样对待他们
that you do you don't make them feel the
你不要让他们有
way that you make me feel you f with me
那种感觉 你让我感觉到你和我在一起
I was very dominant I CH one single day
我非常占主导地位我CH有一天
Fu did you decide to Ru my [\h__\h] life
你决定Ru我的生活
you ruined my life I tell you I'll tell
你毁了我的生活我告诉你我会告诉
you this I ruin yours yeah you've
你这个我毁了你的是的你
already said that to me so many
已经这么说了 我很多
times I mean it
次我是认真的
thank you that might be a suitable point
谢谢你这可能是一个合适的点
to break me Lord yeah so can I ask you
来打破我上帝是的所以我可以请你
please to return for quarter to two
在两点一刻回来
please thank you very
非常感谢你
much playing the recordings is is not
播放录音不是
about tugging emotional strings
关于拉扯情感琴弦
court it's about the way in which he
法庭上是关于他
spoke to her which demonstrates what I
和她说话的方式，这体现了我所
will suggest as a controlling and
建议的控制和
coercive course of
强制性
conduct hearing of her voice and hearing
行为过程听证会 她的声音，
her breakdown in the recordings and
在录音中听到她崩溃的声音，
that's just awful didn't deserve any of
这太可怕了，不值得经历
this really sad to see what F you went
这些，看到你经历的一切真的很难
through
过，
by the time FIA was 2 3 years old I was
当 FIA 2 3 岁时，我还是
an early teenager I used to babysit FIA
个十几岁的少年，我曾经
a lot when the parents were working she
当父母工作的时候，她经常照顾 FIA，她过去常
used to come here play with us in the
常来这里和我们在
back
street used to play with the toys used
后街玩耍，一起玩玩具，
to hold a hand walk around the garden
牵着手在花园里散步，
有
a lots of Happy memories
很多快乐的回忆
here used to hold on to my Little Finger
在这里曾经抱着 我的小手指
UNC color want some
UNC 颜色想要一些
sweets so we'd go there and do it you
糖果，所以我们会去那里做，你
know F was a big part of the big part of
知道 F 是社区的重要组成部分，
the
community I weren't aware of the of the
我不知道
details that emerged it's a big shock
出现的细节，这是一个很大的震惊，
big shock to
很大的震惊 对
us it's really upsetting that we weren't
我们来说，这真的很令人沮丧，
there to do anything because we we
因为我们不知道发生了什么，所以我们没能在那里做任何事情，
didn't know it was
happening I remember for sent me a text
我记得她结婚后给我发了一条短信，
message after she got
married she wrote slams I hope you're
她写道，我希望你
well inshallah I just wanted to say
一切都好，我只是想
thank you very much for the wedding
非常感谢你的婚礼
money and then I wrote back the next day
钱，然后我第二天回信给
waum Salam
waum Salam，
I hope you're well and settling down
我希望你一切都好，
with your new family remember life never
和你的新家庭安顿下来，记住生活永远不会
goes according to PL it's like a roller
按照PL进行，就像过山车一样，
coaster don't be coming home and mning
不要回家和
about little things to your mom and dad
你的父母谈论琐事，
instead work at your marriage and give
而是努力经营你的婚姻，给予
and take and compromise but I want you
和 接受和妥协，但我希望你
to remember one
记住一
thing
件事，
until until my last day of life your m
直到我生命的最后一天，你的 m
is and will be always here for
会永远在这里等
you I blame
你，我责怪
myself for writing that thing do things
自己写了那件事，做了一些事情，
maybe that was
也许这就是
what stopped her from telling
阻止她现在告诉
me
我 [音乐] 的原因
now will there be questions Mr D
会不会有问题，D 先生，
good Mrs javard I just have a few
好夫人，javard 我只有几个
questions for you would I be right in
问题要问你，我
thinking that after the calls which we
认为在我们听到电话之后，
heard she went back to live with her
她回去和她的
husband cashif anoir is that right
丈夫 cashif anoir 住在一起，对吗，
that's right and when it got to the
对吗，当事情到了
visit to Edinburgh do you know what it
你知道他们访问爱丁堡的
was intended for just a break to get
目的是什么吗？他们只是想休息一下，
away were they hoping that perhaps their
是不是希望
relationship would be improved after the
休息后他们的关系会有所改善？
break there was no um mention of that
根本没有提到这件事
whatsoever did you realize that they'd
你知道他们会
come up stayed in a hotel um taken a day
来吗 住在一家酒店，去
trip to a place called Lo Ness
一个叫 Lo Ness 的地方一日游
是的，
and did she say anything about the trip
她有没有提到这次旅行，
she just says it was very
她只是说这
tiring adult life jackets are stored did
很累，成人救生衣都存放好了，她有
she say anything about having enjoyed
the trip or not you know since this
没有说过这次旅行很愉快，你知道，自从这次
horrific incident I can't recall a lot
可怕的事件发生后，我记不起很多
of
information
信息了
okay did you find out that they had
好吧，你有没有发现他们已经
booked to go for afternoon tea at the
预订了去
Bal moral Hotel yeah I knew that so did
Bal moral 酒店喝下午茶，是的，我知道，所以
it ever cross your mind that their trip
你有没有想过，他们
to Edinburgh might be some kind of
去爱丁堡的旅行可能是
effort on each of their parts to try and
他们双方为了解决问题而做出的某种努力
sort out their differences and go ahead
消除分歧，继续
as a married couple did that ever cross
像一对已婚夫妇一样生活，
your mind no it certainly wasn't the
你有没有想过，这肯定不是
intention of Folia I can't say for the
Folia 的本意，我不能代表被告说，
accused but definitely not FIA so the
但肯定不是 FIA，所以
fact that if they had a good time in
事实上，如果他们在彼此身上都玩得很开心
each other's company visited various
其他人的公司访问了不同的
locations does that do that surprise you
地点，这会让你感到惊讶吗？
the words that F used to me were I'm
F 对我说的话是“我
buying my time I know what I'm doing so
在买时间，我知道自己在做什么”，所以
she was putting on a front doing what
她假装在做
she had to do to leave the
她必须做的事情以离开
accused but I I saw that you gave a very
被告，但 我看到你在 2021 年 9 月 8 日接受警方的一次非常
long interview or a very long statement
长的采访或一份非常长的声明，
to the police on the 8th of September
2021 so 5 days after you heard about her
所以 五天后，你才得知她
death on the third yeah is there a
去世的消息，是的，
reason why you hadn't mentioned to the
你为什么没有向
police that you'd spoken with your
警方透露你已经和你
daughter and that was going to be her
女儿谈过了，而这也是她的
intention well bear in mind I just had
本意，请记住，我刚刚经历了令人
the shocking devastating news that I've
震惊的 一个毁灭性的消息，我
lost my only child in horrific
失去了我唯一的孩子，在可怕的
circumstances so my head was all over
情况下，所以我的脑子一片
the place and you putting that to me I
混乱，你告诉我这个，我甚
can't even
至不
remember whether I said that or not well
记得我是否说过这个，
please don't think I want to put you at
请不要以为我想让你 在
any kind of disadvantage but there is a
任何不利的情况下，但有
something like a 23 pages of typewritten
一份大约 23 页的
script of what you had said at that time
打字稿，记录了你当时说的话
and it just occurred to me that nothing
，我突然想到，没有
like that was mentioned to the
向警方提到过这样的事情，
police that would be of some
这虽然没有什么
significance though wouldn't it that
意义，但不会
after what was intended to be a break
在本该分手之后，
that she was going to leave him my head
她却要离开他，我的脑子
was all over the place I fainted twice
一片混乱，
after giving that statement so I can't
在说完这句话后我晕了两次，所以我不
remember what I said so it comes as a
记得我说了什么，所以这有点让
bit of a surprise you putting that
你吃惊
question to me I thought I had said
问我这个问题，我想我已经说了
it thank you very
非常感谢，
much right uh you're free to go thank
对吧呃你可以自由地走了
you very much thank you so
非常感谢非常感谢
much if the public Galler is full of
如果 公共画廊里都是
relatives of course you're conscious of
亲属，当然你意识到了这
that but it doesn't change anything for
一点，但这对
you as a defense Council the people in
你作为辩护委员会来说没有任何改变，画廊里的人，
the gallery I mean not like the inquiry
我的意思是，不像
that's being made but you can't ever
正在进行的调查，但你永远不能
think I can't ask that question that
认为我 不能问那个
wouldn't ever
永远不会
happen so we'll stop there for today uh
发生的问题所以我们今天就到此为止呃
can I ask you please to be back 410
我可以请你明天回来410到
tomorrow see you then thank
那时见谢谢
you it was tough um it feels like a blur
你这很难嗯感觉像一片模糊是
yeah I can't even remember my
的我 甚至不记得我的
responses I did what I had to do
回答我做了我必须做的事
she obviously found some things
她显然发现有些事情
difficult to remember but that's
很难记住，但这是
understandable to stand on a witness box
可以理解的，站在证人席上，
and then face a jury lawyers and then
然后面对陪审团律师，然后
you add the grief of the case itself
你再加上案件本身的悲痛
that took great
这需要很大的
courage but you never know what view the
勇气，但你永远不知道陪审团会持什么观点
jury
take
Yasmin Javit seen here on the left said
Yasmin Javit（左边）说，
she started to worry about her daughter
FIA a few months after she married
在她嫁给 Kashif anoir 几个月后，她开始担心女儿 FIA，
Kashif anoir she told her son-in-law's
她告诉她女婿的
murder trial he'd been abusive in the
谋杀案审判 他在高等法院表现粗鲁
high court of jusic court number one as
司法法庭一号，作为
Majesty's Advocate against cashi Anar
陛下的辩护律师，对 Cashi Anar
court number
法庭一号
one the members of the jury have heard
陪审团成员听取了
evidence from fia's mother about the
FIA 母亲关于
nature of the abusive
虐待
relationship however the jury cannot
关系性质的证据，但陪审团不能
convict on that evidence
alone have a good day thank you my Lord
仅凭这些证据就定罪，祝你有美好的一天，谢谢 大人，
the next witness is police Constable
下一位证人是警员
Sarah
莎拉·
Joyce
乔伊斯，
I want to show the jury independent
我想向陪审团出示独立
evidence this is someone who has no
证据，此人
connection to the accused or the family
与被告或其家人没有任何关系，
and that is capable of supporting the
并且能够支持
evidence on Friday the 30th of April
2021 were you requested to attend at a
2021 年 4 月 30 日星期五的证据，您是否要求
location at 2139 hours that day yes and
当天晚上 21:39 到达某个地点，是的，
what what was the nature of that work um
那项工作的性质是什么，嗯，
it was a priority call um from um a
这是来自
victim's mom stating that her daughter
受害者母亲的紧急电话，说她的女儿
had come to stay with her away from her
来和她住在一起，远离了她的
husband and that there was controlling
丈夫，而且有控制
and coercive Behavior happening would I
和强制性行为发生，我
be right in saying that your body camera
说得对吗，你的身体摄像机
recorded all of that it did
记录了它所做的一切，是
yes hi you're right good yeah very well
的，嗨，你说得对，很好，是的，很好，
thank you you're right if we sit down
谢谢你，你说得对，如果我们坐下来，
yeah of course thanks very much um so I
是的，当然，非常感谢，嗯，所以 我
think your mom called us um just with
认为你妈妈打电话给我们，嗯，只是
regards to is it husband yeah right okay
问一下，丈夫，对，好吧，
what what's gone on oh um first of all
发生了什么事，哦，嗯，首先，
we're definitely not going to find out
我们肯定不会去查，
is it it's up to you whether you say
这取决于你，不管你说
look I just want to report this and I
看，我只是想报告 我
don't want police to take action yeah I
不想让警察采取行动，是的，我
think the moment just would like face
认为此刻只是想面对，
yeah you know something happens in the
是的，你知道未来会发生一些事情，
future okay so is this the first time
好吧，这是第一次，
like you've come to moms and you've gone
就像你来妈妈那里，你实际上已经走了，
actually I need a bit of time to think
我需要 考虑一下
okay how long have you guys been
你们在一起多久了，
together month four months okay well if
四个月，好吧，如果
it's not working it's not working okay
这行不通，那就行不通，好吧，
um has has he ever has he ever assaulted
他有没有攻击过
you has he ever laid a hand on you or
你，他有没有对你动过手，或者
any I mean it's first all like like yes
其他什么，我的意思是 首先，是的，
he has like I think like the pillow was
我认为枕头
up my face and he's like using like like
放在我的脸上，他就像使用
f and told me
f 一样，并告诉我，
that but like obviously I had the pillow
但显然我有枕头，
though so it was impacting me in the in
所以它对我的影响与
the same as those the face so quite
那些脸一样 所以非常
right so he's got a pillow over your
正确，所以他用枕头压住你的
face punching the pillow your face
脸，用力打你的脸，
yeah can I just say somebody putting
是的，我能说有人把 用
pillow over your face is one thing
枕头捂脸是一回事，
someone then punching that pillow is
用拳头打枕头又是
another thing doesn't matter who's done
另一回事，不管是谁做的，
it that's an assault however because
这都是殴打，因为
it's your husband that's domestic
那是你的丈夫，这是家庭
assault and you know I I think we're
暴力，你知道，我认为我们
both sat here say that is definitely not
都坐在这里说这绝对是
acceptable you what he's saying to her
不可接受的 你知道他对她说了什么吗
you're never going to leave me I'm never
你永远不会离开我我永远不会和
going to divorce you I'm going to finish
你离婚我要和
you I'm going to destroy
你完蛋我要毁了
did FIA want any police action to be
FIA 是否希望警方采取任何行动
taken on this occasion no she just
不，她 只是
wanted it logged thank you very
想记录下来，非常感谢
much Mr D
D 先生，
good I just wanted to clarify the last
我只是想澄清
matter you were asked so she wanted the
你被问到的最后一件事，所以她想让
police to um log the information into
警察将信息记录到
some kind of system is that right yes
某种系统中，对吗，是的，
well to be exact it was her mother who
确切地说，是她的母亲
had made the call to the police is that
已经打电话给警察了，对吗？
right
correct and I think your mother had some
我认为你的母亲也
contributions to what was being said to
对你所说的事情做出了一些贡献，
you as well is that so I think a few yes
所以我认为有一些，是
okay but when it came to the end of the
的，但是当事情发展到最后时，
process she had signed to say that she
她签署了 说她
didn't want a prosecution to follow is
不想被起诉，对吗？是
that right
yes as a defense lawyer you're not
的，作为一名辩护律师，你并不
always standing up to cross-examine a
总是站出来反对 盘问
witness to undermine them thank you very
证人以削弱他们的证词非常感谢
much sometimes you want the information
有时你想要
that the prosecution witness has given
检方证人提供的信息
you want it and you want to emphasize it
你想要它并且你想强调它
the prosecutor might think it has no
检察官可能认为它
relevance at all but you want the jury
根本没有相关性但你希望陪审团
to have a part of that in the Forefront
有一个 在
of their
他们的
音乐
mind Kash is always been a good lad I've
头脑中，Kash 一直是个好小伙子，我
known Kashif to be very outspoken very
知道 Kashif 非常直言不讳，非常
loud uh but as spoken and Loud Kashif is
大声，但正如 Kashif 所说，Kashif
is how humble and doubt Kashif is Kash
是多么谦虚，怀疑 Kashif
did have issues within his marriage but
内心确实有问题 他的婚姻，但当
those issues when you have two people of
你有两个性格坚强的人时，这些问题就会出现，
strong character bearing mind she was a
记住她是一个
solit uh so she had a strong opinion so
孤独的人，所以她有很强的意见，所以
it wasn't very easy for them to actually
他们实际上并不容易
get along with each
相处
other in regards to the evidence that's
关于证据 这
actually been produced it's all about
实际上是关于
marital issues having ups and downs and
婚姻问题的起起伏伏，
the question which the prosecution
检方
hasn't actually put forward is did the
实际上没有提出的问题是谋杀是否
murder actually take place rather than
真的发生了，而不是
all the focus has been on kashif's
所有的焦点都集中在卡什夫的
character um but his character doesn't
性格上，但是他的性格 并不
suggest that he is able to do any
意味着他能够造成任何
physical harm yet to Le commit
身体伤害，但在 Le 犯下
murder after the pleas left I said to
谋杀罪后，我对
FIA look just leave him come home that's
FIA 说，就让他回家吧，这就是
all I wanted her to
我想要她
do but B wanted to get the money back
做的，但 B 想要拿回钱
that he'd stolen from
他偷了
her so she went back to
她的东西，所以她回到了他身边。
him at that time she was very very
当时她非常非常
cautious as to what she was telling us
谨慎地告诉我们她想说什么，
and could tell she was holding stuff
可以看出她在隐瞒一些事情。
hello are you very well sir how you
你好，先生，你好吗？
doing
做
[Laughter]
[笑声]
that's what we wanted to tell you unle
这就是我们想告诉你的，除非
congratulations come here man come here
祝贺你来这里，伙计来这里
come here come here come here come here
来这里来这里来这里来这里
come
on you have an emotional it's fine it's
来吧，你有一种情绪，没关系，
fine man I want to tell
没关系，伙计，我想告诉
your she just says oh I've got something
你，她只是说哦，我有 有件事
to tell you and she was really happy and
要告诉你，她真的很高兴，
she says I'm
她说我
pregnant and I was I I was really happy
怀孕了，我真的很高兴
and when I huged
，当我拥抱
her and did she feel that she was going
她的时候，她有没有感觉到她会
to try and make it go of it at that
试着让这件事过去，
point
um I
嗯，我
guess that was the
想 确实如此，
case
yeah but me and my husband could tell
但我和我丈夫都能感觉到
that things were not
事情不对劲
yes have a good who next please my Lord
是的，请问下一位证人是谁？大人，
the next witness is Crown witness number
下一位证人是 2021 年
seven on the 23rd of August
8 月 23 日的第七号证人，
2021 were you within the antino ward at
您是否在 Leads General Infirmary 的 Antino 病房内
leads General infirmary yes I was was
？是的，
were you aware of the lady in the bed
您知道您旁边床上的那位女士
next to you having visitors her husband
访客她的丈夫
yeah husband right do you recall hearing
是的丈夫对的你还记得听到
a conversation at all I did tell us
过什么谈话吗我确实告诉过我们
about that please um so it was uh when
这件事嗯所以当时
the midwives were all on the change over
助产士都在换班
so there was not really many staff
所以周围没有太多工作人员
around and I could hear him repeatedly
我可以听到他反复
calling her a [\h__\h] and um repeatedly
呼唤 她是个婊子，他反复
saying that he should never have married
说他不应该娶
her he wish he'd never married her and
她，他希望他从来没有娶过她，
that
if if one of them died during child
如果他们中的一个在分娩时死亡，
birth that would be
那就
good if one of them died that would be
好了，如果他们中的一个死亡，那就
good yeah that would be good because
好了，是的，那就好了 很好，因为
they would be free of one
他们会彼此自由，
another he said that she brought out
他说她激发了
this side of
him I was really scared everybody within
他的这一面，我真的很害怕病房里的每个人都在
Ward was there because they were
那里，因为他们
pregnant everyone was there in a
怀孕了，每个人都在一个
vulnerable place and I was really really
脆弱的地方，我真的真的很
worried for her
担心她的
safety all right thank you very much so
安全 对的，非常感谢，所以
so do good I have no questions for this
做得好，我对此没有问题，
swe thank you right that means you
谢谢你，对的，这意味着你
finished giving your evidence and you're
给了 你的证据，你可以
free to go thank you very
自由地走，非常感谢你
much for told about the incident at the
告诉我在
hospital and I invited the parents over
医院发生的事情，我邀请了父母过来
to tell them what I'd gone on and I Tred
告诉他们我所做的事情，我试图和
to discuss it with them but the father
他们讨论，但父亲
was more bothered about uh the police
更担心的是，警察
not getting
involved for said she hadn't contacted
介入，因为她说她没有联系
the police and he was thank goodness for
警察，他很感激，
that I've got my reputation to think
我有我的名誉要
about he wasn't bothered about fo's
考虑，他一点也不关心她的
safety
安全，
whatsoever
so I was thinking if I like this to us
所以我在想，如果我 对我们来说就像这样，
what must be like to fosy when she's on
当她独自一人时，她会是什么样子，
own I was in unknown
我处于一个未知的
territory out of my depth with it
领域，对此我感到力不从心，
all the police gave me some support MERS
所有的警察都给了我一些支持 MERS
hello Carana how can I help and K Nana
你好 Carana 我能帮上什么忙吗，K Nana
was one of them so I contacted them in
是其中之一，所以我联系了 2021 年
May
5 月，
2021 I spoke about the parents and spoke
我和他们谈了谈孩子的父母，谈了
about him the way they were behaving
谈他们
towards FIA and I was shocked when they
对 FIA 的态度，当他们
actually turned around to me and they
转过身来对我
went this is on a based
说这是基于
abuse this was the log from the call and
虐待时，我感到很震惊，这是通话记录，
and we has been disclosed that fosier is
我们 据透露，fosier 正在
experiencing domestic abuse and that
遭受家庭虐待，并且
fia's husband is controlling and he's
fia 的丈夫控制欲很强，他
not allowing her to speak to her own
不允许她和
family he's stolen her money and he
家人说话，他偷了她的钱，
prevents her from looking good or going
还不让她打扮得漂漂亮亮，也不让她去
to the
hairdresses from our perspective this
理发店。从我们的角度来看，这
was quite clearly on a Bas because the
显然是 Bas 的错，因为
abuse that she endured in that household
她在那里遭受的虐待 家庭
was for the purpose of upholding honor
是为了维护荣誉
FIA was told that you can't divorce
FIA 被告知你不能离婚
course um shame was a prevalent Factor
当然羞耻是一个普遍的因素
anosia was expected to dress and behave
anosia 被期望
in a particular way which isn't how she
以特定的方式着装和行为，这不是她
used to dress and behave prior to
在嫁给之前穿衣和行为的方式
marrying into this family so quite
这个家庭，所以很
clearly there was an honor Dynamic that
明显，有一种荣誉动态，这
made it more difficult bosia to get help
使得 bosia 更难获得帮助，
and we provided support to
我们为 asmin 提供了支持。
asmin In some cultures there is a
在某些文化中，有一种
concept known as honor-based killing in
概念被称为荣誉谋杀，
other words shame is brought on the
换句话说，耻辱会给家庭带来耻辱
family and that death is seen as a
，死亡 被视为
method of resolving that matter
解决该问题的一种方法，
consideration was given in this case as
在本案中，考虑
to whether an expert on the concept of
到荣誉谋杀概念的专家是否
honor-based killing should give evidence
应该提供证据，
but that's relevant for motive the crown
但这与动机有关，皇室
never has to prove a
永远不需要证明
motive clearly the crown have got a job
动机，显然皇室 有一份工作，
which is to prove that he pushed fosy
这证明他推开了福西
off Arthur's seat for the purposes of
为了
the trial honor-based abuse doesn't
审判荣誉虐待，
necessarily need to be used
不一定需要使用亚瑟王座，
because you don't want to risk confusing
因为你不想冒险让
the jury who might be unfamiliar with
可能不熟悉
what honor based abuse
荣誉虐待的陪审团感到困惑，
is I want to show the jury that the
我想向陪审团表明，暴力
violence was escalating in its nature
just days before they traveled to
在他们前往爱丁堡前几天，事件性质不断升级。
Edinburgh
C we have CCTV footage and I will also
我们有闭路电视录像，我也会
have a completely independent witness to
有一个完全独立的事件证人。
the events
I'm going to put on the screen label
我要把标签七放在屏幕上，
seven entitled CCTV El coats
标题是闭路电视 El 科茨
Road do you recognize that person the
路，你认识那个人吗 那位
lady yeah that's the lady yes it is
女士，是的，就是那位女士，是的，是的
是的
how was she the lady that you saw
她怎么样了，你看到的那位女士很
distressed she just broke down crying
痛苦，她刚刚哭了起来，
she she just cried um I did say to her
她刚刚哭了，嗯，我确实告诉过她
to pH the police and she said no she was
要报警，她说不，她是 我
going and get a car and go to my mom's
要开车去我妈妈
house did another car appear on the
家，现场有没有出现另一辆车？
scene yeah it was a male that got out
是的，下车的是一名男子，
and she said oh no it's his dad that's
她说哦不，是他爸爸
come to take me I don't want to go I
来接我，我不想去，我
said you don't need to go I'll take you
说你不要 不用走，我带你去
and she said no and she got in the car
，她说 没有，她上了车，
and she
went all right thank you
一切都很好，谢谢。
I just found it very
我只是觉得这很
emotional
令人
distressing
沮丧，
yeah you've been so incredibly strong
是的，你
throughout this whole thing was
在整个过程中一直非常坚强，这很
difficult yes I show just St you know
困难，是的，我只是表现出圣，你知道，不知
somehow bumped into a by coincidence and
怎么撞到了 巧合的是，
then notd find out then I would stick
然后没有发现，然后我会坚持
with the light glue did you notice the
使用光胶你有没有注意到
the car that came that was his dad so he
那辆车是他爸爸所以他
knew you can't say he didn't know
知道你不能说他不知道
anything her mother she know they were
任何东西她的母亲她知道他们是
happy but she were involved in their
快乐，但她参与了他们的
things I never involved because I never
事情，我从来没有参与，因为我从来没有
seen
看到
anything they were very happy very very
任何事情，他们非常幸福，非常
happy couple every family has up and
幸福的夫妻每个家庭都有
down they do talk loud my son talks loud
起起落落，他们说话很大声，我的儿子说话很大声，她
she talks lot they all same they walk
说了很多，他们都一样，他们走
very happy and she was with Kashif she
得很开心，她 和卡什夫在一起时她
wasn't happy and she was ending the
并不开心，她要结束这段
relationship why did she came to
关系，为什么她要来
Scotland when she fell with me and my
苏格兰，当她和我坠入爱河时，我
cried La she was our daughter not their
哭了，拉，她是我们的女儿，不是他们的
daughter we believe when a girl comes to
女儿，我们相信当一个女孩来到
your family she's your daughter my
你家时，她就是你的女儿，我的
daughters are
女儿
married when engag she says kha I want a
订婚时她说，我想要一枚
diamond ring you know how much that cost
钻戒，你知道我花了多少钱
6,300 I going back here from police she
6,300 我回到这里 警察，她
was our daughter we still think that
是我们的女儿，我们仍然认为那个
family is thinking wrong well I'm not
家庭的想法是错误的，好吧，我没有
thinking wrong I said I nothing else to
想错，我说我没什么可
say I'm
说的了，
af after the incident where he was
在他
trying to drag her into the car F he
试图把她拖进车里的那件事发生后，他
said I'm going to leave
说我 离开
him
他，
his behavior was just absolutely
他的行为实在太
horrifying so she contact a divorce
可怕了，所以她联系了离婚
lawyer hi there I
律师，嗨，我
was divor we do have specialists in our
离婚了，我们家庭团队里有专家，可以
family team that can definely have a t
with you is it still a safe environment
和你谈谈，现在你家里的环境还安全吗
for you at home at the moment
um you take the time it's why it's why
你花点时间，这就是为什么
we want to just make sure that you're
我们只想确保你
okay you currently just at work at the
没事，你现在在工作，
out on a walk and so what I will do is
出去散步，所以我要做的就是，
I'm just going to put just a little bit
我只需要
in the M nobody knew what was going on
在 M
apart from FY and me and her father we
除了 FY 和我以及她父亲之外没有人知道发生了什么，我们
were like once we get f is safely home
想，一旦我们把 f 安全带回家，
we'll tell my family there's no need to
我们就会告诉我的家人，现在没有必要
tell anybody now cuz this could
告诉任何人，因为这可能会
escalate I wanted to F it to come home
升级，我想 F 它
then and then there but there was a
然后回家，但有一个
problem the perpetrator's family had
问题，肇事者的家人
organized a Lima party which is a
组织了一个 利马派对是
wedding party thrown by the groom
新郎方举办的婚礼派对，
side was all about putting other people
她把其他人
first and she wanted to cause as minimal
放在第一位，她想
damage as possible
尽可能减少损失，
and she said let me get this over and
她说让我把这件事
done with and then I'm going to leave
做完，然后我就要离开了
him fosy had a smile on her face but me
他 fosy 脸上带着微笑，但我
being F's mother I could tell that she
作为 F 的母亲，我可以看出她
was very unhappy and she was putting on
非常不开心，而且她在
front
面前摆出一副
[音乐] 的样子，
after the b a party we're going to
派对结束后我们要去
Edinburgh on a
爱丁堡
break obviously I didn't want fos to go
休息一下，显然我 不想让 fos 去
to Edinburgh but she was
爱丁堡，但她
adamant it was like I know what I'm
坚持要去，就像我知道自己在
doing I've got this
做什么，我已经做到了
Mom and she said in 5 days time I'll be
妈妈，她说 5 天后我就会
back home for
回家
good
the plan was that they were coming back
计划是他们
on the Saturday which was F's birthday
周六回来，那天是 F 的生日
and she was going to say to him I'm
，她会对他说我要
going to go home cuz my mom's got some
回家，因为我妈妈给我买了一些
presents for me and then she wasn't
礼物，然后她
going to go back
就不回去了
that was the plan was was going to come
计划是
home and we were going to celebrate
回家，我们 要一起庆祝
together my the next evidence was given
我的下一个证据是
on commission that's the legal name for
在委员会上提供的，这是它的合法名称，
it but all it is it's a pre-trial
但它只是一份审前
recording of evidence
证据记录，
okay I'm going to lead evidence from an
好吧，我将从一位
American Tourist who was in the same
美国游客那里获得证据，他当时在同一个 在
same hotel as FIA and the accused the
day before the events on Arthur
亚瑟座位事件发生前一天，与 FIA 和被告住在同一家酒店，
seat please describe what you heard the
请描述一下你在
uh evening of the 1 we had heard a loud
1 日晚上听到了什么，我们听到隔壁
uh disagreement going on in the room
房间里传来一阵很大的争吵声，
adjacent to us was it something that
sounded like an argument it was a very
听起来像是在争吵吗 是
loud intense argument from a male and a
一名男性和一名女性之间发生的激烈争吵，
female at least male and female voices
至少有男性和女性的声音，
what time would you say this disturbance
你认为这场骚乱发生在什么时间，
took
place I'd say approximately 8:00 p.m.
我认为大约是晚上 8 点。
all right thank you very
好的，非常感谢。
much I just have a few questions to ask
我只有几个问题想问
you could you tell what the argument was
你，你能说出争论的是什么吗？
about I had no idea could you make out
我不知道你能说出当时
the language that was being used my only
使用的语言吗？我唯一的
assumption was it may not have been
假设是它可能不是
English because I couldn't pick out any
英语，因为我看不出来 不要
specific words or expletives in the
在争论中挑出任何特定的单词或咒骂，
argument okay so it's raised voices but
好吧，所以这是提高的声音，但
the subject matter you don't know what
主题你不知道
that would be and exact words you
那会是什么，你听不清确切的单词，这
couldn't make out is that correct that's
是正确的，这是
correct you described it as occurring
你描述的正确 发生
around 8:00
在晚上8点左右
p.m. could you be perhaps mistaken about
你可能搞错了
the time because there is some CCTV
时间，因为有一些闭路电视
footage which recorded the people in the
录像记录了
adjacent room coming into the hotel at
隔壁房间的人在 9:00 左右 5 分钟左右进入酒店，
about 5 minutes to
9:00 so that would Place perhaps what
所以
you heard at
你可能在
8:00 not having occurred with the
8:00 听到的不是 发生
individuals in the adjacent
在隔壁
room I I mean I don't I don't time stamp
房间的人身上，我的意思是我不知道
when I return after after dinner but I
我晚餐后回来的时间戳，但我
would assume that it would be about
认为应该是
8:00 but it certainly could have been
8点左右，但肯定可能是
9 all right thanks very much I don't
9点，好的，非常感谢 我
have any further
没有其他
questions I wanted the Judy to
问题了，我希望朱迪
understand the state of the relationship
了解你们的关系状况，
but when you decide to call a witness
但当你决定传唤证人时，
things will not always go well you just
事情并不总是顺利的，你
have to learn to not get too flustered
必须学会​​不要太慌乱，
about it but now I will go back and Lead
但现在我会 回去找到导致谋杀案
evidence about the events which give
发生的事件的线索证据
rise to the murder
that day had spoken to her about 2:00 in
那天下午2点左右和她谈过，
the afternoon just ask how she was doing
只是问她过得怎么样，
and she was saying
她说
fine that evening I sent her text
很好，那天晚上我给她发了
messages and what we're going to go for
短信，什么 我们要去
a short
散
walk because she was pregnant
散步，因为她怀孕了，
thought Oh short walk that's probably
我想哦，散散步，那可能
near the hotel near the
靠近酒店
shops I asked her have you eaten and she
我问她你吃过什么商店，她
said yes went to W
说是的，去了W
M magic aute than Witnesses CH number 90
M magic aute，然后证人CH 90号
Emma
Emma
Todd I want to show the jury how FIA and
Todd我想向陪审团展示FIA和
the ACC were behaving on the way to
ACC在前往
Arthur's seat so I'm going to call the
Arthur's seat的路上是如何表现的，所以我要打电话 负责
CCTV coordinator who was on the case I'm
此案的 CCTV 协调员，我
going to start with item 31 Waverly
要从第 31 项开始，Waverly
station now pause it and you see two
站，现在暂停一下，你看到有两个
people at wly station steps leading down
人在 Wly 站台阶上，通往
into the station is that correct that's
车站的台阶上，这是
correct yeah and and who are they H that
正确的，是的，他们是谁 H
is cashif anoir and that is FIA
是 cashif anoir 那是 FIA
Shabad
Shabad
does Mr Anwar appear to have something
安瓦尔先生手里好像有什么东西
in his hand it appears to be something
好像是
similar to a mobile phone yes
类似手机的东西 是的
right again does Mr Anwar appear to have
对了 安瓦尔先生手里好像有
something in his hand um yes it appears
什么东西 嗯 是的 好像是
to be a mobile phone
again would it be fair to say within a
再次成为一部手机，是否可以公平地说，在
sequence of really a few minutes the
几分钟的时间内，该
device or whatever it is has been
设备或任何设备已被
accessed on several occasions
多次访问过，
yes right thank you very
是的，非常感谢
D先生，
good the footage we've been looking at
我们一直在看的录像
so far has um depicted the two people
到目前为止，嗯描绘了 两个人
walking arm in- arm have I picked that
手挽手走着，我理解得对吗？
up correctly it would appear to be yes
看起来是的，
okay almost all the way the they are
好吧，几乎一路上他们都
closely in each other's company
紧紧地依偎在一起，
physically close to each other certainly
身体上靠得很近，当然是
arm in arm for a l of
手挽手，
bit now when it got to the point of
现在当 事情发展到
being outside the parliament the lady
议会外面，那位女士
had the telephone because she so
拿着电话，因为她
obviously was taking some photographs
显然自己在拍一些照片，
herself is that right yes and as she
对吗？当她
walked off to join him she has the phone
走过去和他会合时，她拿着电话，对
yeah is that right so it it looked as if
吗？所以看起来好像
she had
caught up with him put her arm into his
追上了他，把胳膊伸进他的
arm and then taken her arm out of his
胳膊里，然后又把胳膊从他的胳膊里抽出来
arm and done something do you know if
，做了些什么，你知道
she was putting her phone in her bag she
她是否把手机放在了包里，
she may have been I don't know I I can't
她可能已经这样做了，我不知道，我不知道
really tell from that to be honest does
说实话，
that mean that you weren't really
这是否意味着你并没有真正
looking at it that closely no I'm
仔细观察它？不，我正在
looking at it closely but it's it's hard
仔细观察它，但从
to tell from a distance no I please
远处很难分辨。不，请
don't think I'm trying to criticize you
不要认为我在试图 批评你
I'm just asking you about the detail
我只是问你关于细节的问题，
here you were asked a number of
你被问到了很多
questions about his having the phone but
关于他有电话的问题，但
she quite obviously ends up with the
她显然最终把电话拿到了
phone outside the Parliament building
外面 国会大厦
she certainly does at the front but I
她肯定在前面，但我
cannot tell from there what she does
无法从那里知道她在
with the phone there I could never say
那里用电话做什么，我无法
for certain the last person who's
肯定地说最后一个
noticeably got the phone is the lady
明显拿到电话的人是那位女士
herself that's is that correct I saw you
本人，对吗，我看到你了，
thank you very
非常感谢
[音乐] 他们
much once the leave the Scottish
离开苏格兰
Parliament there's no CCTV cover of the
议会后，没有 CCTV 拍摄他们所
route that they take
走的路线，
so consequently there's no evidence at
因此，没有任何证据表明
all of how they were as they ascended
他们在那天晚些时候登上
Arthur's
亚瑟的
seat later on that evening I sent her a
座位时的情况。我给她发了一个
message asking her how's your
信息问她你的散步怎么样
walk and she didn't
，她没有
answer
回答
I got worried but then I thought well
我很担心，但后来我想
she's pregnant she's probably really
她怀孕了，她可能真的
tired and she's probably gone to
很累，她可能已经
sleep and I thought well as soon as I
睡着了，我想，
wake up in the morning I'll ring
早上一醒来我就会 我会
her the next day at 5:00 in the morning
第二天早上 5 点给她打电话 [音乐]
there was a knock on the
有人敲门
door
did you ask him if he had a telephone he
你问他有没有电话他
said that he didn't have his phone on
说他没有带手机
him and how was he in my opinion seemed
他在我家怎么样 舆论似乎
calm domestic violence has no place in
平静了家庭暴力已经不存在 在
Islam naturally your body just fills
伊斯兰教中，你的身体自然会充满
rage who received this whole it was
愤怒，接受这一切的人是
Kashi fur's father you're not being
卡什·弗的父亲，你没有被
asked to find him guilty of being a
要求判定他是一个
horrible nasty guy you're being asked to
可怕的讨厌的人，你被要求
decide whether he has committed a
决定他是否犯了
murder I'm just like hope he doesn't get
谋杀罪，我 我只是希望他不会被
quitted he was writhing in pain but she
放弃，他痛苦地扭动着，但当
was able to speak to me when I asked her
我问她问题时，她能够和我说话，
questions did you ask her what had
你问过她发生了什么事吗？我问了
happened I did
yes
[音乐] [
音乐]